My Lens Upgrade: From Nikon 24-200mm f4-6.3 to Nikon 24-120mm f4 S
In my ongoing photography journey, I recently made the decision to change my primary lens, swapping out the Nikon 24-200mm f4-6.3 for the Nikon 24-120mm f4 S. This upgrade represents a significant step in my pursuit of quality and versatility in my photography. Today, I’d like to share the reasons behind this change, the features I’m excited about, and how this decision will influence my photography going forward.
Why I Chose the Nikon 24-200mm Initially
When I first entered the world of mirrorless cameras, the Nikon 24-200mm lens was a game changer for me. Here’s a deeper dive into why I initially chose it:
1. Affordability and Accessibility
The Nikon 24-200mm was an excellent entry point into the mirrorless system. As someone eager to explore photography but cautious about making a large investment, its relatively low price made it a perfect choice. It allowed me to experience the benefits of a mirrorless camera without breaking the bank, making it a wise decision for a beginner.
2. Versatility for All Types of Photography
One of the biggest draws of the 24-200mm lens was its versatility. With such a wide focal range, I could tackle a variety of photography styles—landscapes, portraits, street photography, and even wildlife—all with a single lens. This meant I only needed to carry one lens, which significantly simplified my shoots and reduced the weight of my gear bag. The convenience of having an all-in-one lens made it easier for me to focus on the art of photography rather than worrying about switching lenses.
3. Creative Flexibility
The large focal range gave me the freedom to shoot how I wanted, when I wanted. Whether I was capturing expansive landscapes or tighter shots of interesting details, the 24-200mm enabled me to switch between wide-angle and telephoto shots seamlessly. This flexibility was invaluable as I was still learning my style and discovering what types of photography I enjoyed most.
4. Learning About My Photography Preferences
Using the 24-200mm lens allowed me to analyze the metadata of my images later. I could see which focal lengths I gravitated toward the most, helping me refine my photographic approach. This learning process was crucial in identifying my strengths and preferences as a photographer, and it guided my future gear decisions.
5. Ease of Use
The 24-200mm was designed with user-friendliness in mind. Its autofocus system was quick and accurate, making it easier for me to capture moments without fumbling with settings. This feature helped me build my confidence, particularly during spontaneous shooting situations where time was of the essence.
The Drawbacks of the 24-200mm Lens
While the 24-200mm served me well, it wasn't without its drawbacks:
1. Variable Aperture
The variable aperture meant that my exposure and depth of field would change as I zoomed in and out. This inconsistency could be frustrating, especially when trying to achieve a specific look in my images. I often found myself adjusting settings mid-shoot, which could disrupt my creative flow.
2. Slight Softness in Images
Despite being better than any other lens I had used prior, I began to notice a slight softness in my images. While this lens was adequate for general photography, the pinpoint detail I desired wasn’t always there, particularly when I was shooting in demanding conditions. As I grew more experienced, I became increasingly aware of this limitation.
3. Limited Low-Light Performance
The variable aperture also affected my ability to shoot in low-light situations. As I zoomed in, the maximum aperture would narrow, making it harder to maintain proper exposure without increasing the ISO. This limitation became a significant consideration as I explored different styles of photography.
Why I Upgraded to the Nikon 24-120mm f4 S
After careful consideration, I decided to trade in the 24-200mm for the Nikon 24-120mm f4 S. Here’s why this choice felt right:
1. Focus on Useful Focal Ranges
I realized that when I shot past 120mm, I was typically already at the maximum 200mm. This meant the focal ranges in between were often unused, making them unnecessary for my style. The 24-120mm focuses on the ranges I actually utilize, streamlining my photography and allowing me to be more intentional with my shots.
2. Complementary Lens Options
I also own a Nikon 100-400mm lens, which covers the longer focal ranges. This means I could still capture distant subjects effectively; I just needed to plan ahead and switch lenses when necessary. The 24-120mm fills the gap nicely, providing a versatile range for general shooting while leaving my options open for long-distance photography.
3. Consistent Aperture Control
The locked f4 aperture of the 24-120mm allows for better control over both exposure and depth of field, regardless of whether I’m zooming in or out. This consistency is crucial for achieving the desired look in my images, particularly when I want to maintain a shallow depth of field.
4. Size and Weight Similarity
Interestingly, the size and weight of the 24-120mm lens are almost identical to that of the 24-200mm. This means my gear bag remains manageable without any added bulk, which is essential for me as I often carry my camera for extended periods.
5. Higher Quality Build
As part of Nikon's "S" line, the 24-120mm is built to a higher quality standard than non-S lenses. This means better clarity, improved weather sealing, and enhanced glass coatings, all of which are vital for my shooting style. I feel more confident taking this lens into various shooting conditions, knowing it’s designed to withstand the elements.
6. Filter Compatibility
With a diameter of 77mm, the 24-120mm shares the same filter size as my 100-400mm lens. This compatibility simplifies my workflow and saves me from investing in new filters, making my transition smoother.
Why I Didn’t Opt for an f2.8 Lens
While I considered f2.8 lenses, I ultimately decided against them for several reasons:
1. Cost: The price of an f2.8 lens is typically double that of an f4 lens, which is a significant factor for someone like me who is still building their kit. Budget constraints are always a consideration in my gear decisions.
2. Size and Weight: f2.8 lenses are generally larger and heavier, which could complicate portability. As someone who enjoys spontaneous shooting, I value a setup that allows for easy mobility.
3. Filter Size Compatibility: The filter size of an f2.8 lens is greater than my current filters, meaning I would need to invest in new ones. This added cost and hassle didn’t appeal to me, especially when I already have compatible filters.
4. Focal Range Limitations: Many f2.8 lenses I looked at only go up to 70mm. I preferred the extra 50mm of focal range provided by the 24-120mm, as it better aligns with my shooting needs.
My Satisfaction with the 24-120mm Lens
Though I haven’t had the 24-120mm lens for long, I am very happy with it so far. The consistent f4 aperture allows for greater creative control, and I’ve noticed a significant improvement in detail and clarity in my images. The build quality is also reassuring, making me feel more confident about my investment.
A New Learning Experience
I’ve already begun to explore new creative possibilities with the 24-120mm. The improved image quality allows me to experiment with techniques I might have shied away from in the past, such as tighter compositions and more intricate details. I’m excited to see how this lens will expand my artistic expression.
Future Considerations
As for future upgrades, I’m not certain that I would switch to an f2.8 zoom lens unless it offers a focal range that includes both 24mm and 100mm. Instead, I plan to invest in more prime lenses in the near future, particularly those with wider apertures than f2.8. These prime lenses will provide me with even more creative control and flexibility, allowing me to push the boundaries of my photography.
Conclusion
Switching from the Nikon 24-200mm f4-6.3 to the Nikon 24-120mm f4 S lens has been a thoughtful and rewarding decision. With improved quality, greater creative control, and a better fit for my shooting style, I’m excited to see how this lens will impact my photography in the long run. As I continue to explore and capture the world around me, I look forward to sharing my journey and the stunning images that come from it. Here’s to new adventures, better gear, and a never-ending passion for photography!